The Chief Justice and the Pope

Chief Justice John Roberts sided with liberal members of the Supreme Court last week in an historic vote largely upholding Obamacare. He did so for many cogent reasons that Pope Benedict XVI might do well to ponder.

First, Chief Justice Roberts took a positive, expansionist view of his leadership role. He was looking for a way to preserve Obamacare rather than demolish it. He was thinking about what was best for Americans and the Supreme Court that he leads. He did not wish to give the Republicans still another enormous 5-4 victory and further diminish the court's reputation for objectivity and fairness.

Chief Justice Roberts is almost as isolated from public pressure as the Pope and both men, of course, have life tenure. Surprisingly, it would appear that the Chief Justice is capable of seeing the big picture better than the Pope. The court that will forever bear his name is in serious trouble, deeply divided and increasingly bitter with each other and the public. (Justice Scalia went out of his way recently to dis President Obama and the president recorded his displeasure with the third branch of government and the Citizens v. United case in a recent State of the Union message. Moreover, I thought Justice Scalia's derisive reference to reading the 2,000 page Affordable Health Care law was truly tasteless and offensive. I do expect supreme court justices to read legislation. That's what we're paying them to do.)

As for the Pope, the Roman Catholic Church is in abysmal shape, stricken as it is with doctrinal division, pedophile priests and incredible myopia. With the greatest respect, the Pope needs to search his heart and move to change errant policies and ease the agony of his flock. People of good will everywhere suffer for their catholic friends and pray for their well being.

It's pure fantasy, I imagine, but what an opportunity there is now for healing! What if Pope Benedict XVI were to come to Yankee Stadium in the sack cloth of a penitent, barefoot, no golden garb, no regal trappings, and humbly express his most abject contrition for his sins and those of his bishops in the performance of their sacred duties. What if he apologised for persecuting American nuns, and abandoned some of the dumb orthodoxies of his church, like permitting only men to be priests. Oh, what rivers of grace would flow down, what glory would shine upon Yankee Stadium as the Holy Spirit rushed through the crowd as it did on Pentecost. The whole world would know that the Pope was thinking about the needs of his people and the sacred image of the Roman Catholic Church. That's what the Pope is supposed to do, kind of like the Chief Justice of the world's most powerful nation - a veritable city on a hill that, with God's help, has led the world in the past and now needs a little refurbishing.